Where the 4% rule comes from
Financial planner William Bengen published "Determining Withdrawal Rates Using Historical Data" in 1994. He tested every 30-year retirement starting from 1926 and found that a first-year withdrawal of about 4%, adjusted for inflation, never ran out for a portfolio holding 50–75% stocks. Three Trinity University professors confirmed it in 1998 with different assumptions.
Where it falls short
- Longer retirements. Early retirees funding 40–50 years usually start at 3.25–3.5%.
- Rigid spending. Real retirees adjust; flexible "guardrail" rules let you start higher.
- Fees and taxes. A 1% advisory fee eats a quarter of a 4% withdrawal.
Test your own plan with the withdrawal calculator, or see how long a specific balance lasts, such as $1 million or $500,000.
Questions people ask
What is the 4% rule?
In the first year of retirement, withdraw 4% of your portfolio; every year after, withdraw the same dollar amount raised by inflation. William Bengen (1994) found that this survived every 30-year period in US market history he tested with a 50–75% stock portfolio. The 1998 Trinity study reached a similar conclusion.
How much do I need to retire using the 4% rule?
Multiply the yearly spending your savings must cover by 25. If you need $40,000 a year beyond Social Security, you need $1 million. At 3.5% the multiple is about 28.6.
Is the 4% rule still valid?
It is a reasonable starting point for a 30-year retirement, not a guarantee. Morningstar's annual safe withdrawal research has put the safe starting rate between roughly 3.3% and 4% in recent years, depending on bond yields and valuations. Longer retirements and rigid spending call for a lower rate; willingness to cut spending after bad years allows a higher one.
What is the 7% withdrawal rule?
There is no widely accepted "7% rule" for withdrawals. Taking 7% a year, raised with inflation, has historically depleted portfolios in well under 30 years in many periods: at a steady 5% return it lasts about 18 years. A 7% figure sometimes refers to an assumed average stock return, which is a different thing.
Does the 4% rule include taxes?
No. The 4% is the gross withdrawal. Tax on Traditional account withdrawals comes out of it, so include taxes in your spending figure, or hold more in Roth accounts.